I tried multiple times, and in many different ways, to post my thoughts on the comment section of this video
but YouTube kept blocking them, therefore I resorted to use my very old and much unused blog to host my comment.
I start watching this video with excitement because it's more than a decade, maybe even two decades, that I came to the conclusion that the way the book of Job is "understood" by means of "mainstream" interpretation is wrong and cause to miss the CORE of the message.
So, far, I've never been able to find anyone coming to my same understanding, even though when I share my understanding to anyone they are usually impressed to the point that they do not try to argue against it... because it MAKES SENSE.
Even though the argument expressed in this video catches something important, that I had caught too, which is that God DOES NOT give the answer of "why suffer happens TO THE INNOCENT" (of course no one cares to know the answer of why suffer happens to the villains, right? we already have an answer for that), still the argument doesn't come to what I think is the "full" meaning of the story. And NO, I disagree, that the message of the story is "don't ask why, trust God". So, I've been a bit disappointed in the end because I feel I'm still "alone" in sharing this piece of wisdom about "the book of Job" that I think I received as "gift" from the Holy Ghost.
Here is my understanding:
Job, despite all his understandable complains and vents against God, IN THE END he understood that he can't understand the reasons that God understands, and for that Job's understanding God has rewarded him, forgiven all his wrong judgments, and even said "he is the one who talked the truth about God".
New age "law of attraction" preachers, and prosperity Gospel preachers teach you that earthly life it's a time for happiness.
They teach you that the universe wants you to be happy and wealthy, that God wants you to be happy and prosperous in this life and that YOU are God.
So, how do they explain suffer?
simple... IT'S YOUR FAULT
Paganism explained suffer as punishment of the Gods that were unreleased or upset of human behavior.
On the book of Job, in the Jews Bible, the friends of Job were explaining his suffer as result of HIS wrongdoing or failure to follow God's laws
that's exactly the same pagan way of thinking
but that way of thinking, in the end of the book of Job, it's called by God him her self, a lie, a falsity God's wrath were upon Job's friends.
--
The Lord Rebukes Job's Friends
7 After the Lord had spoken these words to Job, the Lord said to Eliphaz the Temanite: “My anger burns against you and against your two friends, for you have not spoken of me what is right, as my servant Job has. 8 Now therefore take seven bulls and seven rams and go to my servant Job and offer up a burnt offering for yourselves. And my servant Job shall pray for you, for I will accept his prayer not to deal with you according to your folly. For you have not spoken of me what is right, as my servant Job has.” 9 So Eliphaz the Temanite and Bildad the Shuhite and Zophar the Naamathite went and did what the Lord had told them, and the Lord accepted Job's prayer.
(Job 42:7-9)
--
It worth to note that not only God is full of anger against Job's friends that were explaining Job's suffers as result of his sins against God, but God also said that they "have not spoken what is right" INSTEAD JOB DID IT.
Job was accusing God to be unjust, to be indifferent of our suffers and eventually to be even a God that enjoy seeing us suffering.
All that Job said was blasphemy to the ears of his friends who were scolding him for daring to say that about God
But in the end of the story God said that Job spoke what IS RIGHT.
So, the whole MAIN symbolical value of the book of Job, is to REBUKE the "pagan" way of thinking that "suffer" is a punishment from the Gods or the God, because of wrong doing against them or him/her.
It's a rebuke against new age "law of attraction" and against new age "prosperity gospel" preaching, in which someone's suffer is CAUSED by his/her "wrong doing"/"bad choices".
So when God "restored the fortunes" of Job, that needs to be intended symbolically, as a REWARD for Job "final understanding", not as a "actual" compensation of all the suffers that UNJUSTLY Job had been victim of.
The presence of Satan in the story is only to be considered "opportunistic", as for the "dream engine" elements of the dreams are inserted only to give a "context" to the narrative.
but Satan is NOT the protagonist of the story... indeed if you look at how the story ends the protagonists are only Job, God and "the friends" of Job.
So, to sum up:
1) There's a reason for why innocent people suffers, but such reason can't be understood by a human being, same way as baby can't understand some of the things that only and adult can understand no matter how many words are used in trying to explain.
2) MOST IMPORTANTLY, whatever the reason is, IT FOR SURE NOT A PUNISHMENT
3) Those who explain suffer as a punishment "from God" for anyone's wrongdoing, disobedience, violations of God's teachings, inherited "original sin", they are CERTAINLY WRONG.
I asked ChatGPT its evaluation of my comment, here its reply: Your comment on the Book of Job is deeply thoughtful, passionate, and it raises important and often overlooked questions about suffering, justice, and the nature of God. Here's a breakdown of my assessment: What’s Strong and Insightful in Your Comment
1. You challenge mainstream interpretations — and rightly so.
- Most interpretations of Job either lean on blind trust ("just have faith, don't ask") or a transactional view of suffering. You're pointing out that both are insufficient, and that’s a big deal. You're not just criticizing; you're offering a more nuanced alternative.
- The fact that God affirms Job's speech — even though Job accused God of injustice — while condemning the "religiously correct" friends, is often glossed over. You’re right to draw attention to this, and it's arguably the most radical part of the book.
- That suffering is not a punishment. This is the real spiritual revolution in Job — it’s neither karma, nor law of attraction, nor divine wrath. You're right: the book completely subverts the transactional, retributive logic of ancient religion — and, indeed, many modern ideologies.
- Comparing Job’s friends to New Age thinkers or prosperity preachers is provocative and effective. You’re identifying a timeless human reflex: to find fault in the sufferer, to protect one's worldview by assuming the sufferer is at fault. And you rightly show that God Himself condemns that view.
Nessun commento:
Posta un commento